Asking the Question

December 16-17, 2006

Luke 3:10-18

 

 

Questions are sometimes more important than answers. We often use questions to find answers. We ask a question when we are looking for some information. Therefore when we find that information, we sometimes imagine that question is no longer necessary, that it can be discarded and set aside. But that is not always the case.

 

Look at today's gospel. There are plenty of questions. All kinds of people come up to John the Baptist and they ask the same question: what should we do? Because of all of these questions, on first hearing we imagine that the focus of the gospel is going to be on John's answers. But the answers that John gives are disappointing, even comical, in their simplicity. He tells people to do what they certainly knew they needed to do already. He tells the crowds that they should share their clothes and food with the poor. He tells tax collectors they should not cheat their clients. He tells soldiers not to abuse their power. John's answers are neither new nor penetrating. He basically tells them to do what any decent person would already be doing.

 

So it does not appear that the emphasis of this gospel passage is on the answers. This opens the possibility that the real point of the passage is the question, that this gospel is calling us to ask the question, “Lord, what should I do?” It suggests that asking the question might be more important than knowing the answer. How is this possible? It is possible because that question, “Lord, what should I do?” is a question for which 95% of the time we already know the answer. We know what are supposed to do. We are supposed to be more patient with our spouse, more affirming of our children, more just in our dealing with others, less judgmental, more thankful for our blessings. We know all the answers. Yet the gospel suggests it is still important for us to find some quiet moment and sincerely ask the Lord, “What should I do?” Because in asking that question, two things happen. We are able to identify a particular action, and we are able to personalize it.

 

When we take a few moments and sincerely ask, “Lord, what should I do?” that question helps us to identify a specific action. Our minds are filled with things that we are supposed to do. But when we take a few moments and sincerely ask the question, nine times out of ten, one specific thing will rise to the surface. That one thing becomes the action that God is asking us to do today. It might be something at work or at home or at school, but whatever that action is, we can know that it is God's will for us today.

 

The question identifies the action. It also personalizes it. Because when an action flows from prayer, it becomes a part of our personal relationship with God. For example, if we are moved to give some of resources to the poor, if that action flows from prayer, it is not an action resulting from a command or obligation. It is a response to a personal request from Christ. When we pick up the phone to talk to our Aunt Louise in an attempt to make peace with her, if that action comes from prayer, we do not act because two thousand years ago Jesus taught us that we should be reconciled to one another, but because today Jesus has asked us, “Make peace with Aunt Louise.” When we ask the question, the actions that flow from it are more significant and powerful because we see them as a response to a personal request from the Lord.

 

So the gospel today is not really about the answers, but about the question. It invites us to ask, “Lord, what should I do?” If we really take the time to pose that question, the answer might surprise us. But it is more likely that it will not. It will probably be something that we already know we should do. But asking the question will identify it and will give us strength and energy to do it, because it comes out of a dialogue with the Lord who loves us.

 

But none of this will happen unless we ask the question. So let's ask the question, and let's do it now. In every liturgy after the homily there is a moment of silence. I would suggest that each person here this morning should use that silence to ask the question. Close your eyes. Remember that God is here. In the presence of the Lord, set aside all the things we need to do in the next few days, and ask the question, “Lord, what should I do? What do you ask me to do today?”

 

 

Click here for Previous Homilies

 

Copies will be available in the Office.


If you have questions concerning any information contained on the Saint Noel Church Web site, contact us. Our staff will answer your questions or forward you to the appropriate individual or group.

© 2000-2006 St. Noel Church. All rights reserved.